Some people believe that competition for high grades motivates students to excel in the classroom. Others believe that such competition seriously limits the quality of real learning.

Write a response in which you discuss which view more closely aligns with your own position and explain your reasoning for the position you take. In developing and supporting your position, you should address both of the views presented.

From the moment students begin their academic careers, they are faced with pressure to perform well. The fear that their peers, teachers, and parents will judge them harshly if they fall behind in their academic standings constantly motivates students to work harder. Some teachers even impose punishments for poor performance, such as detention, that further the fierce competition to remain at the top of the class. However, the competitive nature of the academic environment often limits students’ learning by placing too much emphasis on the grades they receive rather than the quality of their work. The grades that students receive are often the only measure of their academic performance. As a result, they devote all of their time and energy into studying for the tests, not the creative or analytical work that tests require of them. The result is that many students do not learn as much as they might if they had not had this focus placed upon them

When students enter high school, they are bombarded with different study techniques and learning materials to help them get good grades. They are told to study in silent study halls, do all of their homework, and memorize their times tables. However, this constant stress does not motivate students to learn. Instead, it leads them to focus more on getting good grades than on understanding concepts. When they are forced to study for hours on end, they no longer see the purpose of learning. Instead, they see it as a chore that they must complete to ensure their high grades. Additionally, the grades that students get on the quizzes and tests they receive are often based on memorized information, not their ability to think critically. As a result, they do not know how to integrate that information into their own work. In college, students often encounter more complicated problems and require deeper thought to solve them, but they continue to study in the same manner that they studied in high school, and their performance suffers accordingly

Students often learn to study for tests only during the semester or the year that they are taking them. As a result, they do not retain the information that they worked so hard to learn. This leads them to study the same material again the next year, and once again their grades suffer. The cycle continues until they realize that studying for tests does not help them learn the material. Instead, it hinders the learning process because they become frustrated and bored when they attempt to review the same material multiple times. If students were able to study for tests throughout the year, they could better retain the information that they have learned, and then they could apply it when taking the standardized tests that are required by colleges

This competitive approach to learning is not an ideal way for students to learn. It is not beneficial to them nor to the people around them. Students do not retain as much information as they should, and the tests that they are required to study for are less effective than they could be. When students prioritize their grades over the quality of their work, they are not only limiting their own learning, but they are also hindering the progress of others in their classrooms.

Total
0
Shares
Total
0
Share